Medical journals

Free medical journals

Home page of the "C.V.P. medical" journal

Paper Submission

Regulations

Editing Board

Contact

Scientific Articles

Comments on the published papers

 

Medical journal articles

The review checklist that the Committee of Judges use to provide feedback on the articles:

 

 

Evaluation Criteria

Comments to the author(s)

Originality

 

Does the paper address a new problem or one that has not been studied in depth?

Does the paper present new approaches?

Does it point out differences from related research?

Does it contribute to the field?

 

Research methodology

 

Are the research axes or/and aims clearly described?

Are the sample and procedure clearly described?

 

Findings and data analysis

 

Is the proper statistics or qualitative analysis used?

Are the results described and evaluated?

 

Quality and clarity

 

Is the paper well written?

Does the paper motivate the research?

Do conclusions connect with aims and findings?

Does the paper carefully evaluate the strengths and limitations of its contributions?

 

References

 

Are the references relevant to the topic?

Is the literature up to date?

 

Technical issues

 

Is the paper organized in a logical fashion?

Is the paper written in clear English?

 

 

 

RECOMMENDATION

PUBLISH

 

PUBLISH WITH MINOR REVISIONS

 

PUBLISH WITH MAJOR REVISIONS

 

REJECT

 

 

 

You may add any further comments, advice or explanations on a separate sheet.

 

You can also write on the body of the paper and send it back to us.

 

© Copyright-VIPAPHARM. All rights reserved

Scientific journals